Los Amigos Restaurant New Castle Indiana | Best Mexican Food in Henry County

The Best Salsa in Henry County Isn't Where You'd Expect

Los Amigos Restaurant sits in a strip mall on the south side of New Castle, the kind of place you'd drive past without a second thought. But walk inside on any given Wednesday night and you'll find families crowded into booths, a steady stream of takeout orders, and tables covered in empty baskets that once held what might be the best chips and salsa in Henry County.

I'm not being dramatic. The salsa here has a cult following.

What Makes Los Amigos Worth the Trip

Los Amigos nails the basics so consistently that people drive from surrounding towns specifically for dinner here. It's become the busiest Mexican restaurant in New Castle for good reason.

The shredded beef chimichanga is a standout—crispy, hot, and perfectly executed. The Chef's Special is what regulars order by name, and the taco salad keeps people coming back. If you're feeling adventurous, the Hawaiian plate (hold the pineapple, according to locals) and fajita nachos are worth trying.

The beef and cheese nachos are simple but done right. The beef tacos hit that perfect balance of straightforward and satisfying. Sometimes the best meal is just a large queso and whatever sounds good that day—people rarely leave disappointed.

Service: Fast When It's Packed

Los Amigos runs at one speed: busy. From open to close, this place is packed. Walk in after 1:00 PM and you'll likely find a crowd at the front door—people checking out, others waiting to be seated.

And somehow, they still get food out fast. We're talking 10 minutes or less from order to table, even during the lunch rush. Drinks arrive in minutes, your order gets taken almost immediately, and then your food shows up hot and ready before you've finished your first basket of chips.

The servers are polite and prompt, bending over backwards to make sure you have everything you need. They keep the pace moving without making you feel rushed.

Portions That Make Sense

One thing regulars consistently mention: the portions are generous. You'll probably take leftovers home, which is exactly what you want. Dinner combo plates come loaded—think enchiladas, burritos, and tamales on one plate—and everything arrives hot.

The Atmosphere

Los Amigos has three separate dining areas, which is perfect if you're coming with a large group or if you'd prefer a quieter spot. The décor is colorful and festive, creating a welcoming environment that feels authentic and lively.