Carson Whiteman

July 5, 2025

Temptations Restaurant: Comfort Food in New Castle, IN

Craving Hoosier comfort food? Temptations in New Castle serves daily home-cooked classics like meatloaf, pot pie, and fried pork chops.

Hidden Gems
Food

Temptations: Comfort Food with a Hoosier Kick

Temptations restaurant in New Castle, Indiana has been serving hardy and soulful plates of comfort food to customers since 2010, ensuring all guests get a feel of Hoosier hospitality through its mouth-watering menu and unmatched hospitality. It’s a hidden gem worth exploring.

Home Cooking in the Crossroads

Whether you’re in for a lazy brunch, an out-of-this-world meatloaf, or satisfying your sweet tooth through its fantastic desserts that come free with every meal; Temptations is sure to have you full of memories and home style cookin’ that will leave you with your mouth opening every time your elbow moves.

Signature Menu Items

At Temptations, the menu changes daily, making it a game of chance with comfort food that’s impossible to lose.

  • Meatloaf (Tuesday): Baked to perfection and smothered in gravy, it tastes like Sunday dinner – only made every Tuesday.

  • Chicken Pot Pie (Wednesday): With a flaky and golden crust stuffed with tender chicken and vegetables, its chicken pot pie will make you feel like cozying up to a blanket – even in the summer.

  • Country Fried Chicken with Gravy (Thursday): Crispy. Juicy. Smothered in gravy. You’re all set.

  • Fried Pork Chop (Friday): Served hot and crispy, the fried pork chop brings the crunch and comfort that only a Midwest kitchen can.

Make the Drive

Temptations features one location, nestled in New Castle right off of State Road 3. Whether you’re in town to catch a basketball game at the historic New Castle Fieldhouse, or got off on the wrong exit of I-70, grab yourself a seat and treat yourself to a reminder of what good old fashioned Indiana cooking tastes like. 

Temptations: Comfort Food with a Hoosier Kick

Temptations restaurant in New Castle, Indiana has been serving hardy and soulful plates of comfort food to customers since 2010, ensuring all guests get a feel of Hoosier hospitality through its mouth-watering menu and unmatched hospitality. It’s a hidden gem worth exploring.

Home Cooking in the Crossroads

Whether you’re in for a lazy brunch, an out-of-this-world meatloaf, or satisfying your sweet tooth through its fantastic desserts that come free with every meal; Temptations is sure to have you full of memories and home style cookin’ that will leave you with your mouth opening every time your elbow moves.

Signature Menu Items

At Temptations, the menu changes daily, making it a game of chance with comfort food that’s impossible to lose.

  • Meatloaf (Tuesday): Baked to perfection and smothered in gravy, it tastes like Sunday dinner – only made every Tuesday.

  • Chicken Pot Pie (Wednesday): With a flaky and golden crust stuffed with tender chicken and vegetables, its chicken pot pie will make you feel like cozying up to a blanket – even in the summer.

  • Country Fried Chicken with Gravy (Thursday): Crispy. Juicy. Smothered in gravy. You’re all set.

  • Fried Pork Chop (Friday): Served hot and crispy, the fried pork chop brings the crunch and comfort that only a Midwest kitchen can.

Make the Drive

Temptations features one location, nestled in New Castle right off of State Road 3. Whether you’re in town to catch a basketball game at the historic New Castle Fieldhouse, or got off on the wrong exit of I-70, grab yourself a seat and treat yourself to a reminder of what good old fashioned Indiana cooking tastes like. 

Temptations: Comfort Food with a Hoosier Kick

Temptations restaurant in New Castle, Indiana has been serving hardy and soulful plates of comfort food to customers since 2010, ensuring all guests get a feel of Hoosier hospitality through its mouth-watering menu and unmatched hospitality. It’s a hidden gem worth exploring.

Home Cooking in the Crossroads

Whether you’re in for a lazy brunch, an out-of-this-world meatloaf, or satisfying your sweet tooth through its fantastic desserts that come free with every meal; Temptations is sure to have you full of memories and home style cookin’ that will leave you with your mouth opening every time your elbow moves.

Signature Menu Items

At Temptations, the menu changes daily, making it a game of chance with comfort food that’s impossible to lose.

  • Meatloaf (Tuesday): Baked to perfection and smothered in gravy, it tastes like Sunday dinner – only made every Tuesday.

  • Chicken Pot Pie (Wednesday): With a flaky and golden crust stuffed with tender chicken and vegetables, its chicken pot pie will make you feel like cozying up to a blanket – even in the summer.

  • Country Fried Chicken with Gravy (Thursday): Crispy. Juicy. Smothered in gravy. You’re all set.

  • Fried Pork Chop (Friday): Served hot and crispy, the fried pork chop brings the crunch and comfort that only a Midwest kitchen can.

Make the Drive

Temptations features one location, nestled in New Castle right off of State Road 3. Whether you’re in town to catch a basketball game at the historic New Castle Fieldhouse, or got off on the wrong exit of I-70, grab yourself a seat and treat yourself to a reminder of what good old fashioned Indiana cooking tastes like. 

Written By:

Carson Whiteman

Written By:

Carson Whiteman

get indiana newsletter

Be the first to know about trending events and new attractions.

Free. Straight to your inbox. Every weekday morning.

get indiana newsletter

Be the first to know about trending events and new attractions.

Free. Straight to your inbox. Every weekday morning.

get indiana newsletter

Be the first to know about trending events and new attractions.

Free. Straight to your inbox. Every weekday morning.

Hidden Gems Sponsor

Khamis Fine Jewelers

Hidden Gems in Indiana are powered by Khamis Fine Jewelers, a trusted name in fine jewelry for the last 30 years in Indianapolis. At Khamis Fine Jewelers, they search the world for hidden gems — stones with character, pieces with soul. Whether it's a rare sapphire, custom design, or diamond with a story, your perfect piece is waiting to be discovered.

Hidden Gems Sponsor

Khamis Fine Jewelers

Hidden Gems in Indiana are powered by Khamis Fine Jewelers, a trusted name in fine jewelry for the last 30 years in Indianapolis. At Khamis Fine Jewelers, they search the world for hidden gems — stones with character, pieces with soul. Whether it's a rare sapphire, custom design, or diamond with a story, your perfect piece is waiting to be discovered.

Hidden Gems Sponsor

Khamis Fine Jewelers

Hidden Gems in Indiana are powered by Khamis Fine Jewelers, a trusted name in fine jewelry for the last 30 years in Indianapolis. At Khamis Fine Jewelers, they search the world for hidden gems — stones with character, pieces with soul. Whether it's a rare sapphire, custom design, or diamond with a story, your perfect piece is waiting to be discovered.

Small Town Breakdowns

Share Your Favorite Small Towns

Help us uncover Indiana's most unique small towns. Submit your favorites and we'll highlight what makes them special!

Small Town Breakdowns

Share Your Favorite Small Towns

Help us uncover Indiana's most unique small towns. Submit your favorites and we'll highlight what makes them special!

Small Town Breakdowns

Share Your Favorite Small Towns

Help us uncover Indiana's most unique small towns. Submit your favorites and we'll highlight what makes them special!

Hidden Gems

Share Your Indiana Hidden Gems

Know a secret spot in Indiana? Share your favorite hidden gem—trails, eats, oddities, or local legends—for a chance to get featured.

Hidden Gems

Share Your Indiana Hidden Gems

Know a secret spot in Indiana? Share your favorite hidden gem—trails, eats, oddities, or local legends—for a chance to get featured.

Hidden Gems

Share Your Indiana Hidden Gems

Know a secret spot in Indiana? Share your favorite hidden gem—trails, eats, oddities, or local legends—for a chance to get featured.