Growing up in Middlebury, one thing I always looked forward to was a summer stop at Mooey’s for a scoop of ice cream. It’s a hometown favorite that’s all about big flavor, friendly smiles, and that small-town charm Indiana does best.

The Scoop on Mooey’s

Mooey’s isn’t just an ice cream shop — it’s a Middlebury moment. Locals flock here for a cone after school, families gather after ballgames, and visitors quickly realize this is one of those must-stop spots that make small towns so lovable.

You’ll find a colorful mix of hand-dipped ice cream, soft serve, and specialty sundaes, along with classic treats like milkshakes, banana splits, and floats. Whether you’re a chocolate lover, a caramel dreamer, or someone who always goes for the fruity swirl, Mooey’s has something to make your taste buds do a happy dance.

Yes, the ice cream is every bit as good as people say, but Mooey’s doesn’t stop at dessert. They’ve also got savory snacks and sandwiches that hit the spot. Hungry for more than a cone? Try one of their freshly made sandwiches, perfect for lunch or an easy dinner on the go. And if you’re craving something salty with your sweet, their soft pretzels are a fan favorite — warm, chewy, and just the right balance of buttery and salty. Pair one with a cold milkshake, and you’ve got the ultimate treat combo!

If you're hunting for more frozen treats across the state, check out our guide to the best ice cream shops in Indiana.

A Sweet Stop Along the Pumpkinvine Trail

One of the best parts about Mooey’s is its prime location right along the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail. Cyclists, walkers, and families out for a day of adventure love stopping here to rest and refuel. There’s something extra satisfying about enjoying a cone or a sandwich after a scenic ride through Indiana’s countryside. With plenty of outdoor seating and that laid-back, summer-evening vibe, Mooey’s is the perfect trail-side treat spot.

While you're in the area, consider checking out other nearby spots like Nappanee, the Wellfield Botanic Gardens in Elkhart, or planning a full trip with our South Bend-Mishawaka travel guide.

A Small-Town Stop Worth Smiling About

From sweet scoops to salty bites, Mooey’s Ice Cream serves up a little something for everyone. It’s the perfect mix of fun, flavor, and friendly faces.

So next time you’re in northern Indiana, make sure to swing by Mooey’s Ice Cream. Whether you’re craving a cone, a sandwich, or a soft pretzel, you’ll leave with a full belly and a happy heart.

Hours of Operation

Like many small-town ice cream shops, Mooey’s only operates during the warmer months from spring into October. Be sure to follow Mooey’s on Facebook for all the latest news, treats, and specials.