Taylor Huff

December 9, 2024

Bremen's Secret Pizza- The Wooden Peel

Is this best pizza in Indiana? We went to The Wooden Peel to let you know how it is.

Hidden Gems
Food
Bremen's Secret Pizza- The Wooden Peel
Bremen's Secret Pizza- The Wooden Peel
Bremen's Secret Pizza- The Wooden Peel

Bremen Indiana is one of those small towns you’ve never heard of that are sprinkled all over Indiana. If you ever find yourself there and ask a local what to eat for dinner, they will probably say, “Try The Wooden Peel”. It’s the local cozy pizza joint and popular is an understatement. Locals don’t blink at a two-hour wait for their favorite slice of pie. There is also a town rumor of something with scales living in the basement…

Award Winning Pizzas and more

The Wooden Peel was voted best pizza in northern Indiana in 2015 and made the 2024 Pizza Marketplace TOP 100 Movers & Shakers. Their garbage pizza is a must-try. It’s loaded with sausage, ham, pepperoni, green peppers, mushrooms, black, and green olives. You can customize your pizza with over 25 toppings to choose from. Not a pizza lover? Don’t worry! They also have sandwiches, salads, and a munchies menu. Munchies like breaded mushrooms, pickle chips, and stuffed breadsticks.

Low Key and Loved

The Wooden Peel knows how to keep that local hometown feel. They don’t have a website. They don’t take reservations. They have a simple Facebook page and a loyal customer base. If you call on a weekend have some patience. People wait hours for these pizzas. It wouldn’t be a hidden gem if it weren’t worth the wait.

A Small Town Gem That’s Worth The Visit

Check out their Facebook page for the latest trivia night they’re hosting, then grab some friends and enjoy a pizza and a beer. What’s a small-town dive without a local mystery? It has been rumored there’s an alligator in the basement of the Peel… guess you’ll have to stop in to find out.

Written By:

Taylor Huff

Written By:

Taylor Huff

get indiana newsletter

Be the first to know about trending events and new attractions.

Free. Straight to your inbox. Every weekday morning.

get indiana newsletter

Be the first to know about trending events and new attractions.

Free. Straight to your inbox. Every weekday morning.

get indiana newsletter

Be the first to know about trending events and new attractions.

Free. Straight to your inbox. Every weekday morning.

Khamis Fine Jewelers

Hidden Gems in Indiana are powered by Khamis Fine Jewelers, your trusted Indianapolis jeweler for the last 30 years. While not all gems are found in plain sight, shop their curated selection of extraordinary stones and designs you won't find anywhere else.

Khamis Fine Jewelers

Hidden Gems in Indiana are powered by Khamis Fine Jewelers, your trusted Indianapolis jeweler for the last 30 years. While not all gems are found in plain sight, shop their curated selection of extraordinary stones and designs you won't find anywhere else.

Khamis Fine Jewelers

Hidden Gems in Indiana are powered by Khamis Fine Jewelers, your trusted Indianapolis jeweler for the last 30 years. While not all gems are found in plain sight, shop their curated selection of extraordinary stones and designs you won't find anywhere else.

Since You Liked This Article…

Check out our latest podcast episode for even more Hoosier stories, local voices, and insider tips.

Featured Episode

Stephanie Eppich Daily, founder of Send A Friend Lasagna in Indianapolis, shares how she turned loss into a food business that heals, comforts, and celebrates. Hear her story of growth, resilience, and what’s next for her lasagna delivery service.

Featured Episode

Stephanie Eppich Daily, founder of Send A Friend Lasagna in Indianapolis, shares how she turned loss into a food business that heals, comforts, and celebrates. Hear her story of growth, resilience, and what’s next for her lasagna delivery service.

Featured Episode

Stephanie Eppich Daily, founder of Send A Friend Lasagna in Indianapolis, shares how she turned loss into a food business that heals, comforts, and celebrates. Hear her story of growth, resilience, and what’s next for her lasagna delivery service.

Featured Episode

Stephanie Eppich Daily, founder of Send A Friend Lasagna in Indianapolis, shares how she turned loss into a food business that heals, comforts, and celebrates. Hear her story of growth, resilience, and what’s next for her lasagna delivery service.