Award Winning Pizzas and more
The Wooden Peel was voted best pizza in northern Indiana in 2015 and made the 2024 Pizza Marketplace TOP 100 Movers & Shakers. Their garbage pizza is a must-try. It’s loaded with sausage, ham, pepperoni, green peppers, mushrooms, black, and green olives. You can customize your pizza with over 25 toppings to choose from. Not a pizza lover? Don’t worry! They also have sandwiches, salads, and a munchies menu. Munchies like breaded mushrooms, pickle chips, and stuffed breadsticks.
Low Key and Loved
The Wooden Peel knows how to keep that local hometown feel. They don’t have a website. They don’t take reservations. They have a simple Facebook page and a loyal customer base. If you call on a weekend have some patience. People wait hours for these pizzas. It wouldn’t be a hidden gem if it weren’t worth the wait.
A Small Town Gem That’s Worth The Visit
Check out their Facebook page for the latest trivia night they’re hosting, then grab some friends and enjoy a pizza and a beer. What’s a small-town dive without a local mystery? It has been rumored there’s an alligator in the basement of the Peel… guess you’ll have to stop in to find out.
