On East Main Street in Delphi, Indiana sits a breakfast-and-brunch spot that’s quietly becoming a local favorite: the Buttermilk Biscuit Company. If you’re looking for a place that delivers big flavor in a warm, friendly setting far from the big-chain breakfast crowd, this is one to add to your list.

A Bite Above the Rest

As the name suggests, everything here starts with the biscuit. Each one is made from scratch, perfectly buttery, and baked to golden perfection. Crispy on the outside, soft and tender inside — the way a biscuit should be. The menu builds around these fluffy creations, offering both traditional and inventive options.

Favorites include the biscuits & gravy, a classic done right with creamy sausage gravy poured over thick biscuits, and The Oracle, a hearty sandwich stacked with fried chicken, bacon, cheese, and a fried egg. Those with a sweet tooth shouldn’t miss the cinnamon biscuit with vanilla icing, a delightful twist that pairs perfectly with a fresh cup of coffee. Whether you lean savory or sweet, there’s something on the menu to make your morning brighter.

Love a good comfort food road trip? Check out our guide to the best tenderloin sandwiches in Indiana for more Hoosier classics worth the drive.

A Building with a Story

Part of what makes the Buttermilk Biscuit Company special is its setting. The café is located inside Delphi’s historic Niewerth Building, a two-story Italianate-style structure built in 1874. The building anchors the Delphi Courthouse Square Historic District, an area recognized on the National Register of Historic Places for its 19th-century architecture and connection to the town’s canal-era prosperity. The ornate brickwork and preserved details remind guests that this small town has deep roots, and the café honors that legacy by creating a space where community and tradition come together.

Delphi is just one of many Indiana small towns with charm to spare. Explore more in our guide to small towns in Indiana.

Plan Your Visit

You’ll find the Buttermilk Biscuit Company at 124 E. Main Street, Delphi, IN, open early most mornings (closed Tuesdays). Street parking is available throughout the downtown area, and the café’s convenient hours make it easy to fit into your morning plans.

For the full experience, arrive early, grab a cup of its locally roasted coffee, and take your time enjoying the simple charm of downtown Delphi. It’s more than just breakfast — it’s a small slice of small-town Indiana at its best.

Make it a full day trip—Prophetstown State Park and The Farm at Prophetstown are just a short drive away and perfect for working off those biscuits.

Final Bite

If you’re searching for a hidden gem that serves up scratch-made comfort food in a historic setting, look no further than the Buttermilk Biscuit Company. With its flaky biscuits, welcoming atmosphere, and rich local history, this Delphi favorite proves that sometimes the best meals are found off the beaten path.