Best Pizza in Indiana (2025) | Top Pizza Places in Carmel, Greenwood, Evansville & More

Bonus: Lou Malnati’s – Chicago Deep Dish in Indiana

While Lou Malnati’s hails from Illinois, its Indiana locations have made a name for themselves. Known for its deep-dish pizza, this spot offers a hearty option for those who crave that classic Chicago-style pie.

#8 Passione – Best Pizza in Fishers, Indiana

Nestled in Fishers, Passione serves up authentic Italian pizza that’s simply unforgettable. Their attention to detail and high-quality ingredients ensure that each bite is a culinary delight.

#7 Magoo’s California Pizza Kitchen – Best Pizza in Avon, Indiana

Located in Avon, Magoo’s California Pizza Kitchen is all about tradition—with a twist. Their pies are generously topped with cheese and offer a delicious blend of flavors that keeps pizza lovers coming back for more.

#6 I Tre Mori – Authentic Neapolitan Pizza in Indianapolis

They serve the Authentic Neapolitan wood fired 'Za.

This is also a good spot to go grab some pizza or wine!

#5 Krafters – Best Pizza in Carmel, Indiana

Krafters is a must-visit for anyone who loves innovative flavors.

I freaking love Krafters! They were the spot that served me the tenderloin pizza during the Hamilton County Tenderloin challenge.

I do hold my VIP card at Krafters… so I was pumped to see it on the list.

#4 Pangea Kitchen – Best Pizza in Evansville, Indiana

Heading south to Evansville, Pangea Kitchen takes the spotlight with its visually stunning pizzas. I can't wait to visit this fall because their offerings look simply insane!

#3 Iechyd Da Brewing Company – Best Pizza in Elkhart, Indiana

Pizza and craft beer are a match made in heaven, and Iechyd Da Brewing Company nails it. Their stone-fired pizzas are loaded with fresh toppings, and with 30+ beers on tap, there’s always the perfect pairing. For northern Indiana, this is a go-to.

#2 Brittany’s Brick Oven Pizza – Local Favorite in Greenwood, Indiana

The pizza looks amazing… but what i loved even more what the Our Story Section. Scott and Susan run the B-Bops. (That’s what the locals call it.) They seem like just the greatest people. 

#1 Futuro – Detroit-Style Pizza in Indianapolis

I called this over a year ago.

When it comes to the best pizza in Indiana, Futuro in Indianapolis takes the crown. Known for their massive Detroit-style slices with thick, cheesy crusts and bold toppings, Futuro has become a destination pizza joint. Fair warning: you may need a nap afterward.

Quick Q&A: Indiana’s Pizza Scene

Where is the best pizza in Indiana?

Futuro in Indianapolis consistently tops the list, but Carmel’s Krafters and Evansville’s Pangea Kitchen are also highly rated.

What city has the best pizza in Indiana?

Indianapolis has the highest concentration of standout pizzerias, but Fishers, Greenwood, Avon, and Evansville all offer top contenders.

Is Indiana known for a specific pizza style?

While Indiana doesn’t have a single signature style, Detroit-style pizza in Indianapolis and wood-fired Neapolitan pies in Carmel and Greenwood are gaining a reputation.

Where can I find deep dish in Indiana?

Lou Malnati’s serves authentic Chicago-style deep dish at its Indiana locations, making it the go-to for that classic pie.

Final Thoughts: Indiana’s Best Pizza Is Worth the Trip

From Detroit-style slabs in Indy to hidden gems in Greenwood, Avon, and Evansville, Indiana’s pizza scene is full of surprises. Whether you’re craving traditional flavors or bold new combinations, these eight spots prove that the best pizza in Indiana can rival anywhere in the Midwest.

So grab your friends, order a pie (or two), and taste your way across the Hoosier State—one slice at a time. 🍕