The Athenaeum: A Piece of Germany in the Heart of Indianapolis

Taylor HuffWriter

Oct 10, 20262 min read
Red brick Athenaeum building on Mass Ave in Indianapolis with a round turret and a sign reading YMCA Rathskeller Athenaeum Theatre

Found in the vibrant Mass Ave district of Indianapolis, The Athenaeum is one of the city's most unique and historic buildings. With its striking architecture, rich cultural heritage, and lively atmosphere, it has been a gathering place for more than a century. Whether you're visiting Indianapolis for the first time or you're a lifelong Hoosier, The Athenaeum is a destination worth exploring.

Craig Mince, president of the Athenaeum Foundation, joined the Get IN. Podcast to share more about its 130-year history, today’s operations, paranormal activity, and festivals and traditions.

Built by Indianapolis' German Community

The Athenaeum was originally built in the late 1800s by Indianapolis' growing German-American population. Known at the time as Das Deutsche Haus, or "The German House," the building served as a center for education, social activities, music, and cultural events. It quickly became a symbol of the city's thriving German heritage.

Today, visitors can still see many of the original architectural details that make the building stand out. The grand staircases, historic halls, and beautiful brick exterior offer a glimpse into Indianapolis' past.

More Than a Historic Building

While The Athenaeum is rich in history, it is far from a museum frozen in time. The building remains an active community hub filled with businesses, event spaces, and cultural organizations. Visitors can enjoy restaurants, attend performances, participate in fitness classes, or simply wander through the historic corridors.

One of the most popular attractions is the Rathskeller, a German restaurant and beer garden that has become a favorite gathering spot for locals and visitors alike. During the warmer months, live music and outdoor events bring even more energy to the space.

A Center for Arts and Culture

The Athenaeum continues its original mission of promoting culture and community. Throughout the year, the building hosts concerts, festivals, art exhibits, and educational programs. Many local organizations call The Athenaeum home, helping keep the spirit of creativity alive in downtown Indianapolis.

Its location near Massachusetts Avenue also makes it easy to pair a visit with shopping, dining, and exploring one of the city's most walkable neighborhoods. For anyone looking to experience a different side of Indianapolis, The Athenaeum offers a fascinating look at the city's past while remaining an important part of its present.

Frequently asked

Quick answers.

The useful details, answered clearly and without the digging.

01

Where is The Athenaeum in Indianapolis?

The Athenaeum is at 401 E. Michigan Street, Indianapolis, IN 46204, in the Mass Ave district of downtown. Its location near Massachusetts Avenue makes it easy to pair a visit with shopping and dining in one of the city's most walkable neighborhoods.

02

What is The Athenaeum and who built it?

The Athenaeum is a historic Indianapolis landmark built by the city's German-American community, designed by the architectural firm of Vonnegut & Bohn. It was originally known as Das Deutsche Haus, or "The German House," and served as a center for education, social activities, music, and cultural events.

03

How old is The Athenaeum?

The building went up in two phases: the east wing in 1893-1894 and the west wing in 1897-1898. Athenaeum Foundation president Craig Mince calls it a "130 year old building" on the Get IN. Podcast.

04

Why was Das Deutsche Haus renamed The Athenaeum?

Anti-German sentiment during World War I led the members to drop the name Das Deutsche Haus. The name Athenaeum was announced in February 1918.

05

What is the Rathskeller at The Athenaeum?

The Rathskeller is a German restaurant in the basement of The Athenaeum, and it is the oldest continuously running restaurant in Indianapolis. It also has an outdoor biergarten, which is busy in warmer months with live entertainment and festivals.

06

What can you do at The Athenaeum today?

You can eat at the Rathskeller, catch a show at the Basile Theatre, work out at the YMCA, or grab a coffee at Coat Check Coffee. The Athenaeum also hosts events like GermanFest and Christkindlmarkt.

07

Is The Athenaeum a National Historic Landmark?

Yes. The building was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1973 and designated a National Historic Landmark in 2016.

08

Is The Athenaeum haunted?

Craig Mince says yes, calling it a notoriously haunted old German building, and the Athenaeum hosts ticketed overnight ghost hunts. He discusses the building's paranormal activity on the Get IN. Podcast, which you can find on Apple, Spotify, or YouTube.
Taylor Huff

Taylor Huff

Born and raised in Indiana’s 574, Taylor is a business owner, farm wife, and mom who brings local heart to Get IN by giving you insider tips on the state’s hidden gems.

View all posts →

Keep Exploring Indiana

View all articles

Stay IN the Know

Join 25k+ who know where to go, what's happening, and what's worth their time. Free every Thursday, from all 92 counties, positive news only.

118k+72k+116k+25k+ Hoosiers already read itOne email a weekUnsubscribe anytime