How Hoosiers Are Saving Indiana's Historic Buildings

Is there a historic church in your town on the Sacred Places Indiana list? See all 16 grant recipients, what the money fixes and when the next round opens.

Nov 18, 20265 min read
Twin-towered church lit at night, with a glowing rose window and stained-glass windows above the front entrance

Sixteen churches just got help with leaking roofs and crumbling masonry. A general store in Bright is a gathering place again. A Plainfield farmhouse was moved to escape demolition, then survived a fire.

In a lot of Indiana towns, the oldest building on Main Street is a church, a general store or a farmhouse someone's great-grandparents built. Keeping one standing takes money, an owner willing to do the work, and sometimes a public campaign.

Three recent stories from Indiana Landmarks, the statewide preservation nonprofit with nine offices around Indiana, show each of those at work.

1. Money: $2.5 million for 16 historic churches

On Oct. 27, Indiana Landmarks' Sacred Places Indiana Fund awarded more than $2.5 million to 16 congregations around the state for major repairs to their historic houses of worship. It's the fund's fourth round of grants since it was created in 2023 with support from Lilly Endowment Inc.

The grants pay for roofs, masonry, HVAC systems, foundations and accessibility. A few of the projects:

  • St. Francis Xavier Cathedral in Vincennes, built in 1826 and Indiana's oldest Catholic church, received $226,160 for masonry restoration. That adds to an earlier $100,000 award, after consultants recommended a revised scope of work.
  • First Presbyterian Church in Richmond, from 1886, is getting $84,000 for a full roof replacement, which will also protect a Tiffany stained-glass window inside.
  • The Sisters of St. Francis in Oldenburg received $200,000 for foundation repairs at the 1890 Chapel of the Immaculate Conception.
  • St. Mary Byzantine Catholic Church in Whiting, from 1920, is using its $100,000 for accessible restrooms that support its social ministries.

"By offering this critical funding, we hope to help congregations and parishes continue to thrive as spiritual centers," said David Frederick, who directs the Sacred Places Indiana program.

They're matching grants, awarded competitively. Congregations have to show good stewardship and organizational health, and be ready to finish both a capital campaign and construction within two years. Many recipients first go through Indiana Landmarks' New Dollars/New Partners training, which helps congregations find community partners and put underused space to work.

Is your town on the list?

CityCongregationBuiltGrantWhat it fixes
BloomingtonBloomington Reformed Presbyterian Church1926$150,000 + $25,000 planningMasonry tuckpointing
BloomingtonFirst United Methodist Church1909 (rebuilt 1938)$300,000 + $25,000 planningLimestone exterior repair and cleaning
BrazilFirst Presbyterian Church1924$75,000 + $25,000 planningHVAC and a roof replacement to stop leaks
EvansvilleTrinity United Methodist Church1866$250,000First phase of HVAC replacement
Fort WayneRedeemer Lutheran Church1924$100,000 + $25,000 planningRoof, drainage and accessibility
Fort WayneTrinity English Lutheran Church1925$100,000Transfiguration stained-glass window
IndianapolisEbenezer Baptist Church1921$100,000 + $25,000 planningLimestone, roof, stabilization and accessibility
IndianapolisIrvington United Methodist Church1909–1926$100,000 + $25,000 planningHVAC replacement
IndianapolisSt. Timothy's Episcopal Church1969$100,000Full roof replacement
JasperTrinity United Church of Christ1956$100,000HVAC replacement
LaPorteHoly Family Parish (St. Peter's)1930$90,000Rose window restoration
OldenburgSisters of St. Francis1890$200,000 + $25,000 planningChapel foundation repairs
RichmondFirst Presbyterian Church1886$84,000 + $10,000 planningFull roof replacement
Tell CityEvangelical United Church of Christ1907$250,000Roof and masonry restoration
VincennesSt. Francis Xavier Cathedral1826$226,160Masonry restoration
WhitingSt. Mary Byzantine Catholic Church1920$100,000Accessible restrooms

Does your congregation need help? The next round of applications, and the next training cohort, opens in January 2027. Indiana Landmarks suggests starting with a letter of interest. Details are at indianalandmarks.org/sacred-places-indiana.

2. An owner: Renck's Store in Bright

In the unincorporated community of Bright, in Dearborn County near the Ohio line, one building served as the town center for generations.

Thomas H. Gibson built a one-story general store there in the late 1800s. Three generations of Gibsons ran it, and in 1921 they added a second story with stamped-tin ceilings. Mike Renck bought the store in the 1930s and ran it into the 1980s. People came for groceries, gas, hardware and candy, and the name stuck: everyone called it Renck's. Over the next few decades, the building held apartments, a florist, a gun shop and a barbershop.

Jay and June Tucker bought it in 2023. With technical advice from Indiana Landmarks' Southeast Field Office, they restored it:

  • They reconnected the first and second floors.
  • They added thermally modified poplar siding, repaired and reused the historic front door, and added reproduction windows, including a plate-glass storefront.
  • They stripped decades of paint off the 1921 tin ceilings and walls, and echoed the ceiling's fleur-de-lis pattern in the exterior stair railings.
  • They brought back the store's original Coca-Cola chest cooler, now by the coffee counter.

Historic Renck's Store opened in October 2025 as a coffeehouse, with event space upstairs. "We believe places like Renck's Store are not owned so much as they are stewarded," the Tuckers write on their website.

Visit: Historic Renck's Store, 23995 State Line Road in Bright, serves coffee, scones and lunch. Call ahead for hours.

3. A campaign: Plainfield's Little House

The Thomas Little House in Plainfield was saved after a public campaign.

Built around 1890 for farmer Thomas Little, the Queen Anne-style house sat on land his family had owned since 1830. Hendricks Regional Health bought the property in 2017 and scheduled the house for demolition in spring 2021. That set off a public outcry, including an online campaign led by local resident Amanda Engle. Indiana Landmarks put the house on its 10 Most Endangered list in 2023 and met with the health system to push for another plan.

In 2024, Hendricks Regional Health, the Town of Plainfield and new owners Jim Wheeler and Rachael Branham reached a deal: the house would survive if it was moved. It now sits on the northern edge of the property, along Vandalia Boulevard.

Then, in February 2026, an accidental fire started when sunlight hit a solvent being used in the restoration, damaging the front of the house. Wheeler and Branham kept going. They've since repaired most of the damage, installed new curved glass in the curved windows, refinished the original floors, restored the fireplaces, and opened up the entry to show off the wooden staircase. Work on the upper floors continues.

The Little House is a private home, so admire it from the street.

If a building in your town is at risk

  • Nominate it for Indiana Landmarks' 10 Most Endangered list, which has named threatened properties every year since 1991.
  • Contact the regional Indiana Landmarks office near you. Field staff gave the technical advice that shaped the Renck's Store rehab.
  • Speak up locally. The Little House campaign started with residents.

For more places worth the drive, see Indiana's most historic towns.

How we reported this

This feature draws on three Indiana Landmarks articles published in 2026: on the Sacred Places Indiana grants (Oct. 27), Renck's Store (April 29) and the Little House (Oct. 27). We also used WISH-TV coverage of the Little House fire, GIANT fm coverage of the church grants, and Historic Renck's Store's own history page. All of it was checked on Nov. 3, 2026.

Find your local Get Indiana newsletter. Sign up here.

More from the newsroom

Keep Exploring Indiana

Never Miss a Story

Stay IN the Know

Join 25k+ who know where to go, what's happening, and what's worth their time. Free every Thursday, from all 92 counties, positive news only.

Free · One email a week · Unsubscribe anytime