Small Town Breakdown No. 61: Arcadia, Indiana
For this week’s small town breakdown we’re going from Whiteland in Johnson County to Arcadia in Hamilton County. Arcadia is 50 minutes north of downtown Indianapolis, 50 minutes west of Muncie, and 1 hour and 15 minutes southeast of Lafayette.
What’s it like in Arcadia, Indiana?
The motto for Arcadia, Indiana is: “Where small town America still exists.” You’ll see that during any of its seasonal markets, on a visit to Remnant Coffee Shop, and seeing the family-owned Beck’s Hybrids and Woolly Yak Ranch & Winery just outside of town.
The History of Hamilton County and Arcadia, Indiana
Hamilton County was established in 1823 and named for Alexander Hamilton, the first Secretary of the Treasury and one of America’s Founding Fathers. It has been one of Indiana’s fastest-growing counties this century.
Stay IN the Know
Get the best of Indiana delivered to your inbox every week.
Arcadia was first settled in the early 1830s by Hencil Bartholomew and named after the idyllic Arcadia of Greek mythology, which symbolizes a peaceful paradise. The town was platted in 1851, and shortly after it became a main stop along the Indianapolis & Northern Railroad. Arcadia also played an important role in the Underground Railroad, helping enslaved people escape to freedom. Arcadia is located in Jackson Township.
As of the 2024 census, Arcadia’s population is 1,464, making it the seventh-largest incorporated town/city in Hamilton County ahead of Atlanta (737). It is the 271st-largest city in Indiana.
Things to Do In or Near Arcadia, Indiana
Located just off U.S. 31 and only 10 minutes west of Arcadia is Wilson Farm Market, a must-visit spot in Hamilton County. It’s been around since 1968 and sells everything from fresh produce to Amish fry pies, jams, jellies, homemade fudge, freshly baked breads and doughnuts from its bakery, and