Savoring Northwest Indiana: Two Unique Pizzerias That Redefine the Art of Pizza

Taylor Huff

Food

Travel Guide

March 11, 2025

March 11, 2025

Miller Pizza Company 

Found in Gary, Indiana, Miller Pizza Co. is a hidden gem that has been serving up some of the most delicious pies in the region. For those willing to venture up north, this locally loved pizzeria is well worth the trip.

Miller Pizza Co. is known for its generous portions, rich flavors, and a menu that caters to all kinds of pizza lovers. Wheth​​er you crave a classic Chicago-style deep dish with gooey cheese and a buttery crust, or a perfectly crisp thin-crust slice loaded with fresh toppings, Miller’s does not disappoint. The moment you step inside, the aroma of fresh dough, tangy tomato sauce, and bubbling cheese welcomes you like an old friend.

The casual and friendly atmosphere makes it a perfect stop for both locals and travelers alike. The walls, adorned with nostalgic memorabilia, tell a story of a place deeply embedded in the community. The service is just as satisfying as the pizza—fast, friendly, and full of Midwestern charm. 

While the pizzas are the stars of the show, Miller’s also offers a selection of pastas, sandwiches, and appetizers that showcase the same attention to quality and flavor. The garlic knots, dripping with butter and sprinkled with parmesan, are the perfect appetizer. 

A visit to Miller Pizza Co. is more than just a meal—it’s an experience that embodies the heart of Gary. Grab your pizza and take a quick 5 minute drive to Lake Street Beach  where you can eat dinner and watch the waves roll in off Lake Michigan.  Whether you're a pizza connoisseur or just someone looking for a great slice in an unexpected place, this pizzeria is a must-visit. So next time you pass through northwest Indiana, take a detour to Miller’s—you’ll be glad you did.

Battista’s Artisan Pizzeria

If you find yourself in Crown Point, Indiana, and are in search of an exceptional pizza experience, look no further than Battista's Artisan Pizzeria . This cozy establishment has made a name for itself with its handcrafted, wood-fired pizzas that blend old-world techniques with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

The moment you step into Battista’s, you’re greeted with the warm, rustic ambiance of a true artisan pizzeria. The aroma of fire-kissed dough, bubbling cheese, and house-made sauces fills the air. The staff, passionate about their craft, are always eager to recommend favorites and share the story behind their thoughtfully curated menu.

Battista’s prides itself on using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, ensuring each pizza bursts with vibrant flavors. Their menu features an impressive selection of gourmet pies, from the classic Margherita with its perfectly balanced combination of fresh basil, mozzarella, and tangy tomato sauce to inventive creations that push the boundaries of traditional pizza. Each pizza is cooked in a wood-fired oven, resulting in a crisp yet chewy crust that serves as the ideal foundation for their bold and creative toppings.Beyond pizza, Battista’s also offers an array of house-made pastas, fresh salads, and delectable appetizers that showcase the same commitment to quality. 

For those of you interested in American history, Battistas is a hidden gem within a historical gem. The restaurant is located in the old Halls of Justice building of Crown Point. The courtroom is where notorious gangster John Dillinger was arraigned in 1934 the day before his infamous escape from the old Lake County Jail next door. 

For those seeking an unforgettable pizza experience in northwest Indiana, Battista’s Artisan Pizzeria is a must-visit destination. Whether you’re a local looking for your next favorite spot or a traveler craving an authentic, wood-fired masterpiece, Battista’s delivers on all fronts. Make sure to arrive hungry—you’ll want to savor every slice.

Written By:

Taylor Huff

Taylor Huff

Small Town Breakdowns

Share Your Favorite Small Towns

Help us uncover Indiana's most unique small towns. Submit your favorites and we'll highlight what makes them special!

Small Town Breakdowns

Share Your Favorite Small Towns

Help us uncover Indiana's most unique small towns. Submit your favorites and we'll highlight what makes them special!

Small Town Breakdowns

Share Your Favorite Small Towns

Help us uncover Indiana's most unique small towns. Submit your favorites and we'll highlight what makes them special!

Hidden Gems

Share Your Indiana Hidden Gems

Know a special spot in Indiana that deserves more attention? Submit it, and we’ll help showcase it so others can check it out too!

Hidden Gems

Share Your Indiana Hidden Gems

Know a special spot in Indiana that deserves more attention? Submit it, and we’ll help showcase it so others can check it out too!

Hidden Gems

Share Your Indiana Hidden Gems

Know a special spot in Indiana that deserves more attention? Submit it, and we’ll help showcase it so others can check it out too!

Always Stay IN the Know

Get the latest updates and exclusive insights about Indiana directly to your inbox. Join a growing community of insiders and be the first to know about the hidden gems, trending spots, and local attractions that make Indiana unique.

Subscribe

Always Stay IN the Know

Get the latest updates and exclusive insights about Indiana directly to your inbox. Join a growing community of insiders and be the first to know about the hidden gems, trending spots, and local attractions that make Indiana unique.

Subscribe

Always Stay IN the Know

Get the latest updates and exclusive insights about Indiana directly to your inbox. Join a growing community of insiders and be the first to know about the hidden gems, trending spots, and local attractions that make Indiana unique.

Subscribe

Discover the heart of the Hoosier State with Get Indiana, your go-to source for everything Indiana. Dive into a wide range of topics, from local events and hidden gems to business, travel, food, and more. At Get Indiana, we bring you reliable, comprehensive, and engaging articles that keep you connected to the pulse of our state. Enjoy fresh perspectives on community stories, insightful features, and in-depth guides, all crafted with a commitment to accuracy and local pride.

Explore Indiana effortlessly with Get Indiana, your trusted resource for all things Hoosier. Join us on a journey through the diverse and vibrant life of Indiana, delivering a rich and dynamic reading experience.

Discover the heart of the Hoosier State with Get Indiana, your go-to source for everything Indiana. Dive into a wide range of topics, from local events and hidden gems to business, travel, food, and more. At Get Indiana, we bring you reliable, comprehensive, and engaging articles that keep you connected to the pulse of our state. Enjoy fresh perspectives on community stories, insightful features, and in-depth guides, all crafted with a commitment to accuracy and local pride.

Explore Indiana effortlessly with Get Indiana, your trusted resource for all things Hoosier. Join us on a journey through the diverse and vibrant life of Indiana, delivering a rich and dynamic reading experience.

Discover the heart of the Hoosier State with Get Indiana, your go-to source for everything Indiana. Dive into a wide range of topics, from local events and hidden gems to business, travel, food, and more. At Get Indiana, we bring you reliable, comprehensive, and engaging articles that keep you connected to the pulse of our state. Enjoy fresh perspectives on community stories, insightful features, and in-depth guides, all crafted with a commitment to accuracy and local pride.

Explore Indiana effortlessly with Get Indiana, your trusted resource for all things Hoosier. Join us on a journey through the diverse and vibrant life of Indiana, delivering a rich and dynamic reading experience.

COPYRIGHT © GET INDIANA. 2024 / DESIGNED BY TUSCAN AGENCY
COPYRIGHT © GET INDIANA. 2024 / DESIGNED BY TUSCAN AGENCY
COPYRIGHT © GET INDIANA. 2024 / DESIGNED BY TUSCAN AGENCY

GETINDIANA.

MENU

GETINDIANA.

MENU

GETINDIANA.

MENU