Fishers has no shortage of chain restaurants, but Okaya Sushi & Hibachi Kitchen is the kind of place locals mention in hushed tones, like they're not entirely sure they want everyone else to find out about it just yet.
If you've driven past the strip centers on Allisonville Road, you've probably missed it. But for the neighborhood insider, this little spot is delivering some of the best value and freshest fish in Hamilton County.
Here is everything you need to know about Fishers' worst-kept culinary secret.
What Okaya Is
Okaya is an independent, family-owned Japanese restaurant and sushi bar tucked away at 11009 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038, in the same hub as Cafe Korea. It opened quietly with zero massive marketing pushes or loud grand-opening fanfare, which is exactly why it still retains that coveted, authentic "local secret" vibe.
The dining room is cozy, intimate, and minimalist. It's the type of neighborhood joint where the flash belongs on the plate, and the food is left to do the talking. The service is incredibly warm, spearheaded by the owner, Mike, who regulars know as a fantastic host if you manage to snag a seat near the bar.
The Website: okayaindy.com
The Parking: Easy, unbothered parking in the shared strip-mall lot out front.
The Hours: Open Wednesday through Monday from 11:00 a.m. to late evening.
Stay IN the Know
Get the best of Indiana delivered to your inbox every week.
Take Note: Unlike many spots that close on Mondays, Okaya is closed on Tuesdays. Don't make the mistake of showing up on a Tuesday night craving a roll.