The History of Spencer County and Santa Claus, Indiana
Spencer County was established in 1818 from Warrick and Perry counties. It was named for Captain Spier Spencer, who was killed at the Battle of Tippecanoe in 1811, just two years after he was appointed sheriff of Harrison County by Indiana Territory Governor William Henry Harrison.
Agriculture contributed to Spencer County’s growth in the 19th century, and towns like Santa Claus eventually emerged among the wooded hills and farmland.
Santa Claus was officially founded in 1854, originally under the name “Santa Fee.” When the town sought a post office in 1856, they discovered another Santa Fe already existed in northern Indiana, which forced residents to adopt a new name. They wanted to keep “Santa” in the name, and all they could think of was “Santa Claus.” Since that wasn’t a very magical story, a tale developed that the new-name debate happened on Christmas Eve, and when a door blew open during the meeting, children cried out that they heard sleigh bells. The name Santa Claus was meant to be, setting the stage for more than a century of holiday-themed history and attractions.
As of the 2024 census, Santa Claus’ population was 2,657, making it the largest of seven incorporated towns/cities in Spencer County. It ranks as the 187th-largest town in Indiana.
Things to Do In or Near Santa Claus, Indiana
For a deep dive into the town’s history, the Santa Claus Museum & Village offers original letters to Santa dating back over a century, the historic 1880 Santa Claus Church, and the restored Original Santa Claus Post Office from the 1930s where you can write your free letter to Santa. Include your full address with the letter because Santa and his Elves – a group of volunteers who answer thousands of children’s letters each year – write back every December. Santa Claus Museum & Village is also home to a 22-foot-tall Santa Claus statue built in 1935 and a 12-foot Santa Claus mural completed in 2022 that make for perfect family photo spots.
Santa Claus is – surprise, surprise – built for festive shopping. The Santa Claus Christmas Store sells ornaments, holiday décor, collectibles, and treats year-round. Santa’s Candy Castle opened in December 1935 as Santa Claus’ first tourist attraction and the nation’s first themed attraction, and it re-opened in 2006 after being closed for over three decades. Visitors can shop for gourmet popcorn, cocoa mixes, nostalgic candy, and the famous “Frozen Hot Chocolate.”
No trip to Santa Claus is complete without a visit to Holiday World & Splashin’ Safari, one of the Midwest’s top amusement and water parks. It originally opened as Santa Claus Land on Aug. 3, 1946, and included a toy shop, toy displays, a restaurant, themed children’s rides, and appearances by Santa. As the park grew, Santa Claus Land expanded with Halloween and July 4th sections in 1984, so the park’s name was changed to Holiday World. Then in 1993, Splashin’ Safari was added.
Today it’s known for wooden roller coasters like The Voyage, The Raven, and The Legend, Good Gravy! Family Coaster, water coasters like the Cheetah Chase, Wildebeest, and Mammoth, wave pools, and more rides, plus free parking, free unlimited soft drinks and free sunscreen. The park draws families from all over each summer.
Just minutes away from Santa Claus, explore two major historical sites dedicated to Abraham Lincoln’s early life in Indiana. The Lincoln Boyhood National Memorial features a living historical farm and memorial trails. Established in 1932 as a memorial to Lincoln’s mother Nancy Hanks, Lincoln State Park offers cabins, hiking, fishing, and outdoor recreation across 1,700 scenic acres. The Little Pigeon Creek Baptist Church and Cemetery is located in the park and is where Lincoln’s sister Sarah is buried.
Places to Eat or Drink in Santa Claus, Indiana
Be merry at Santa Claus Brewing Co. where you can enjoy pizza, wings, and a great selection of local craft beers. Try the ravioli bites or reindeer balls (soft pretzel nuggets buttered and salt with beer cheese) for appetizers.
Fat Santa’s Pizza and More is a popular spot for families that serves up specialty pizzas like The Fat Santa, Santa’s Supreme, Surfin’ Santa, and Down the Chimney, plus smashburgers, sandwiches, ice cream, and more.
S&S BBQ & Pizzeria is another Santa Claus staple for families with a life-size Grinch inside for a holiday photo op. While you’re there, order the Grinch pizza – a 16-inch pie loaded with one pound of pulled pork, sweet Thai chili sauce, onion, green pepper, and cheese.
Heritage Hills High School
The high school that serves Santa Claus is Heritage Hills High School, located less than five miles west of town. Founded in 1972, Heritage Hills is home to the Patriots, and they compete in the Pocket Athletic Conference. The Patriots have won two IHSAA state titles in school history, both coming in football.
The first came in 2000 when they beat Zionsville 27-24 in overtime to claim the 3A championship and finish a perfect 15-0 season. Santa Claus native Jay Cutler – who was the Patriots’ quarterback – was on the receiving end of the game-winning trick play. Cutler went on to play at Vanderbilt University, was selected as the 11th-overall pick by the Denver Broncos in the 2006 NFL Draft, led the Chicago Bears to the 2011 NFC Championship Game, and played 12 seasons in the NFL.
The second 3A championship came in 2024 when then-junior quarterback Jett Goldsberry led the Patriots past Fort Wayne Bishop Luers, 38-15. Goldsberry was the game’s leading rusher with 177 yards and three touchdowns on 18 carries. Goldsberry was committed to Ole Miss to play safety but with Lane Kiffin’s departure to become the head coach at LSU, decommitted and announced he will be playing college football at Purdue University.
That’s it for small town breakdown No. 46 of 2025. Where should we head next?
