Discover something new in Indiana every week. Join the newsletter.

Discover something new in Indiana every week. Join the newsletter.

The History of Teachers Credit Union and Rebrand to Everwise

Discover how Teachers Credit Union became Everwise and why this South Bend institution still believes in community-first banking after 94 years.

Podcast Summary

On today’s show I sat down with Jason Osterhage, President and CEO of Everwise Credit Union.

Jason shares his journey from Atlanta to Indiana, the rich history and recent rebranding of Everwise – formerly Teachers Credit Union – and the impact of local financial institutions on the community.

He provides insights into the significance of credit unions, the strategic process behind rebranding a 94-year-old institution, and the value of maintaining personal relationships in banking.

Our conversation also touches on Everwise’s community involvement, their day of giving, and Jason’s personal experiences exploring Indiana.

If you like this episode and want to hear more Get IN. episodes where I interview Hoosiers making a difference, visit getindiana.com/podcast

You are going to learn about:

  • The Rich History of Teachers Credit Union

  • The Challenges and Strategies of Rebranding to Everwise

  • Everwise’s Community Involvement and Day of Giving

Check out these great clips from the show:
00:53 Guest Introduction: Jason Osterhage, President & CEO of Everwise
01:58 First Impressions of Indiana
03:54 History and Evolution of Everwise
10:40 The Rebranding Journey: From Teachers Credit Union to Everwise
13:51 Challenges and Strategies in Rebranding
29:13 The Importance of Physical Branches in Modern Banking
34:47 Community Engagement and Day of Giving
35:47 Favorite Communities and Memorable Experiences
36:34 Exploring Indiana's Hidden Gems
37:39 The Origins and Impact of Everwise
39:03 Understanding Credit Unions and Their Role
41:36 The Importance of Banking Local
47:48 Cultural and Geographic Insights of Indiana
56:04 Leadership and Corporate Governance
59:40 Final Thoughts and Reflections

Guest(s)

Jason Osterhage

Date Published

December 24, 2025

This podcast is sponsored by

Sweetwater

Sweetwater, located in Fort Wayne, Indiana, is a large music store and online retailer that specializes in musical instruments and pro audio equipment. It's known for its extensive inventory, expert staff, and dedication to customer service.

Sweetwater, located in Fort Wayne, Indiana, is a large music store and online retailer that specializes in musical instruments and pro audio equipment. It's known for its extensive inventory, expert staff, and dedication to customer service.

Related Get IN. Podcasts

Brandon Noll of Plug and Play shares how Warsaw became the Orthopedic Capital of the World and why Silicon Valley is betting on Indiana startups.

Business & Economy

|

01:17:56

text

text

Brandon Noll of Plug and Play shares how Warsaw became the Orthopedic Capital of the World and why Silicon Valley is betting on Indiana startups.

Business & Economy

|

01:17:56

text

text

Brandon Noll of Plug and Play shares how Warsaw became the Orthopedic Capital of the World and why Silicon Valley is betting on Indiana startups.

Business & Economy

|

01:17:56

text

text

High Alpha co-founder Kristian Andersen talks Indy's identity crisis, tech entrepreneurship, and making Indianapolis Speed City.

Business & Economy

|

01:22:08

text

text

High Alpha co-founder Kristian Andersen talks Indy's identity crisis, tech entrepreneurship, and making Indianapolis Speed City.

Business & Economy

|

01:22:08

text

text

High Alpha co-founder Kristian Andersen talks Indy's identity crisis, tech entrepreneurship, and making Indianapolis Speed City.

Business & Economy

|

01:22:08

text

text

Brad Colver and Lisa Ellis share how Four Finger Distillery grew from a backyard hobby to a craft spirits brand with locations in Noblesville and Lebanon.

Business & Economy

|

00:44:47

text

text

Brad Colver and Lisa Ellis share how Four Finger Distillery grew from a backyard hobby to a craft spirits brand with locations in Noblesville and Lebanon.

Business & Economy

|

00:44:47

text

text

Brad Colver and Lisa Ellis share how Four Finger Distillery grew from a backyard hobby to a craft spirits brand with locations in Noblesville and Lebanon.

Business & Economy

|

00:44:47

text

text

Elements Financial CEO John Huesing talks credit unions vs banks, small business lending, and investing in Indiana communities.

Business & Economy

|

01:18:16

text

text

Elements Financial CEO John Huesing talks credit unions vs banks, small business lending, and investing in Indiana communities.

Business & Economy

|

01:18:16

text

text

Elements Financial CEO John Huesing talks credit unions vs banks, small business lending, and investing in Indiana communities.

Business & Economy

|

01:18:16

text

text

Pat Sullivan shares how Sullivan Hardware evolved from a 1954 startup to an Indiana retail icon through creativity, community events, and customer service.

Business & Economy

|

01:16:53

text

text

Pat Sullivan shares how Sullivan Hardware evolved from a 1954 startup to an Indiana retail icon through creativity, community events, and customer service.

Business & Economy

|

01:16:53

text

text

Pat Sullivan shares how Sullivan Hardware evolved from a 1954 startup to an Indiana retail icon through creativity, community events, and customer service.

Business & Economy

|

01:16:53

text

text

Ed Schwartzman and Nick Williams share BuffaLouie's growth from Bloomington to Carmel and their partnership with IU's Fernando Mendoza.

Business & Economy

|

01:18:31

text

text

Ed Schwartzman and Nick Williams share BuffaLouie's growth from Bloomington to Carmel and their partnership with IU's Fernando Mendoza.

Business & Economy

|

01:18:31

text

text

Ed Schwartzman and Nick Williams share BuffaLouie's growth from Bloomington to Carmel and their partnership with IU's Fernando Mendoza.

Business & Economy

|

01:18:31

text

text

Podcast

Share Your Indiana Podcast Guest

Know someone with a great Indiana story? Nominate them as a guest for the Get IN podcast and help us share real Hoosier voices.

Podcast

Share Your Indiana Podcast Guest

Know someone with a great Indiana story? Nominate them as a guest for the Get IN podcast and help us share real Hoosier voices.

Podcast

Share Your Indiana Podcast Guest

Know someone with a great Indiana story? Nominate them as a guest for the Get IN podcast and help us share real Hoosier voices.

A person in casual attire poses with a person in a vibrant red mascot costume wearing a baseball jersey that reads "Indians," both against a blue backdrop with text promoting "Get Indiana" with Nate Spangle.
A person in casual attire poses with a person in a vibrant red mascot costume wearing a baseball jersey that reads "Indians," both against a blue backdrop with text promoting "Get Indiana" with Nate Spangle.